Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique

Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique

Journal Article Critiques

These critiques should be between 1.5 and 2 pages, double-spaced, in Times New Roman (12 point) font, and with 1” margins on all sides. Please include and APA style cover page, page numbers and headers/sub headers, in text citations, and works cited page.


Summary: The summary should be between 1 and 2 paragraphs. This should briefly explain the authors’ purpose(s), method, and results (main findings in your own words. No numbers.) Keep the summary informative, but concise (less than a page) Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique.

Critique: You should critique the articles based on the following criteria. Be sure to completely and concisely address each point. Remember this should be a critical assessment or the study (objective). DO NOT INCLUDE YOUR OPINION. Paraphrase , no direct quotes.

1. Purpose/Research Question: Determine the authors’ purpose of the research and state it in your own words. Comment on how clearly this was presented in the article.
2. Method: Comment on how appropriate the method used was for addressing the purpose. State if the method was employed effectively.
3. Evidence of Support: Examine the method and results of the article and determine if they helped the authors effectively address the purpose presented. Also discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the evidence and the study as a whole Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique.
4. Real World Application: After reading the discussion section summarize any real world implications the authors suggest. Also give your own suggestions for the real world application of the study and its’ findings.
5. Recommendations: Determine who might benefit from the article, what the benefit may be, and the importance of the benefit. Here you may summarize your subjective judgments of the work and suggestions on how to improve or extend the work.


 Child Food Request: Article Critique

Most children exhibit fewer problems related to health compared to adults. However, obese children bear the risk of becoming overweight in adulthood. They are more susceptible to chronic conditions such as high cholesterol levels, high blood pressure musculoskeletal issues, breathing problems and insulin resistance. According to a research conducted by Center of Disease Control (CDC), obesity affects close to 17% of children in the United States alone (2013) Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique. However, the trend displays great disparities within racial and minority groups.

Specifically, children from minority and immigrant parents are more likely to develop obesity than those from non-minority and non-migrant families. Similarly, children that come from low-income earning families develop prevalence to obesity compared to those from middle-income and high-income earning households. Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique. Children develop obesity due to regular consumption of foods high in sugar, fast foods that contain too much salt and fat, low fruit and vegetable intake, and sedentary behaviors.  It is therefore important to implement nutrition strategies that focus on the determinants of obesity amongst the low- income earning, minority and immigrant families.


Haroldson, Cordell and Haldeman (2015) conducted a research to ascertain the food requests made by pre-school children and the maternal compliance to the children from low-income earning families. Besides, the researchers sought to compare the types of foods preferred by Hispanic and Non-Hispanic families, and the rates of requests.  Their choice of population sample was perfect, since it encompassed a group that experiences the problems enlisted in their topic of study. Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique.


The researchers used a community-based cross-sectional design, where they chose a group from a southern metropolitan area that consisted of 40% African-American Blacks, 50% Caucasians and 8% Hispanics. Participants were recruited in clinics and filled in questionnaires after prior and thorough screening. Collected data was analyzed using the quota and snowball techniques. The methodology used by the researchers was appropriate, since it encompassed a diverse population. Haroldson et al (2015) clearly outlined the main aspects in the research, which included maternal compliance in the form of primary care givers fulfilling a meal request by a youngster, and child food request, outlining the literal request for any foodstuff a child made in a given family. This way, the researchers eradicated any confusion that would arise. Besides, prior screening of participants ensured the scholars obtained accurate results Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique.

Evidence of Support

Haroldson et al (2015) found out that most Hispanic families had less education and low income. Besides, 80% of the mothers fulfilled their maternal compliance by giving out the requested foods without objection. All the children who participated in the sample requested to buy food from the groceries. Flour-based foods were the most requested foods, followed by cheese and sweets. The results from the study confirmed researchers’ purpose. Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique. They were helpful, since they provided a baseline for discussing the causes of obesity in minority and poor households. However, the research did not clearly disclose substantial results on non-minority and high-income families.


The study was instrumental in ascertaining causes of obesity among low-income earning families. Interestingly, low-income earners depict lives where basic needs are not met. However, cases of obesity amongst their children continue to rise. Besides, high rates of compliance may lead to bad choices when buying foods. From the research findings, one can infer that authoritative parenting is vital to good health among young children. Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique.


From the research, parents can learn on how to control their children’s eating habits. Besides, they ought to educate their youngsters on appropriate diets to guarantee proper health.  Government officials ought to review the findings and suggest on appropriate interventions based on causative factors of obesity among marginalized groups in the society. This way, they ensure reduced mortality rates and a healthy population. Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique.


Haroldson, A., Cordell, Z., & Haldeman, L. (2015). Analysis of Child Food Requests and Maternal Compliance in Low‐income Hispanic and Non‐Hispanic Families. Family and Consumer Sciences Research Journal, 44(1), 37-50.

Retrieved from Child Food Requests Journal Article Critique.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top